The Monterey Institute of International Studies...
At this point, the best way I can describe my view of MIIS is by comparing it to democracy:
A democracy is the best system of governance, out of all the arguably as miserable and differing governing principles and philosophies. As I explore the unknown field of Development at this graduate school, I feel like it would be better described as an exploration of what Education is.
Like Development, there are hundreds of thousands of ways of defining and applying the term, but there is no one correct or necessarily better way...
The romanticized debates (exemplified through research) in higher education easily highlight the innovation and capability of the human intellect, but only sponsor the growth of a seeming Idealist ideology, and rarely that of Realism, or for the purposes of this discussion, "trial and error." An idea, however, is only as powerful and useful as its success.
In the fields of Education and Development, however, I feel like little to no progress is being made, as more and more research explores the realms of useless knowledge that has been reworded and phrased on more than several other occasions. The success stories of Education and Development are ignored and knowledge building continues to be constructed on cracked foundations. We are not advancing in either of the fields, because we continue to implement what functions, neither pushing us back or moving us forward maybe due to a fear of politics-- a fear of each other, and even more pressing, a deeply rooted doubt in ourselves.
Research at an undergraduate level, many times at graduate level, and even still common in PhD level work is done to support a point of view that has been ostentatiously debated for hundreds to thousands of years-- There is nothing original about that. Real, in-the-field research is nearly dead, at least in the United States, conceivably pointing to a possible failure within our Educational system. Hmmm.
Another major commonality between Education and Development is that they are both things that people either cringe or rejoice at. The benefits of Education and Development seem to help only the Educators and the implementers of a Development project; rarely is the beneficiary of these services actually in favor of the proposed "progress." These two concepts are inextricably linked, if not one in the same.
I do not mean to demean the work of highly accomplished and merited Fulbright, Boren, or Rhodes scholars, but to remind the everyone in the world that they have a place if they dare to find it against all common misconceptions of what an educated person looks, feels, and thinks like. This is not to say that the education available renders useless, but rather that it must be taken with a grain of salt.
No comments:
Post a Comment